Partner
Nothing automatic happens. Turning down a settlement offer does not close your claim, does not waive your right to compensation, and does not force you into a courtroom. It moves the negotiation to the next round. Most injury claims in Brazos County involve at least one offer that is too low to accept. The real question is what comes after, and that depends on how the offer was made and what Texas law says about it. Scott Scherr, a board-certified Bryan personal injury attorney at The Payne Law Group, can tell you which kind of offer you are holding.
Who Decides Whether to Accept an Offer?
You do. Your attorney values the claim, tells you what the evidence supports, and recommends a course of action, but the Texas Disciplinary Rules of Professional Conduct require a lawyer to abide by the client’s decision on whether to accept a settlement. The signature on the release is yours, and so is the call. Scott Scherr at The Payne Law Group presents every offer that comes in, along with a straight assessment of what he believes a Brazos County jury may do with the same facts.
That distinction matters more than most injured people realize. An adjuster who senses you are unrepresented or eager to close will open low, because a fast, cheap resolution is the entire point of the first offer. Saying no to it is not stubbornness. It is frequently the only way to find out what the claim is actually worth.
What the Insurance Company Does After You Say No
Rejection restarts the conversation rather than ending it. In a typical Bryan-College Station injury claim, the sequence after a refusal looks like this:
- Your attorney sends a written counteroffer supported by medical records, billing, wage documentation, and proof of how the injury changed your daily life.
- The adjuster reevaluates, often after running the new documentation past a supervisor or a claims committee.
- A second offer arrives, usually higher, sometimes only marginally so.
- If the gap stays wide, the parties may agree to mediation, or your attorney files suit to force the issue.
Each round takes weeks rather than days. The trade-off is patience against money, and it is worth understanding that insurers settle for more once litigation becomes a credible threat rather than a bluff.
The Texas Rule That Can Make a Rejection Expensive
Here is the consequence almost no article on this topic mentions, and the one Texans need to know. Most settlement offers carry no downside if you refuse them. A narrow category does. Once a lawsuit is on file, a defendant may serve a formal settlement offer that shifts certain litigation costs onto the party who turned it down. If you reject that kind of offer and the judgment you win comes in at less than 80 percent of what was offered, the court must award the defendant its litigation costs.
Those costs cover court costs, reasonable deposition expenses, fees for up to two testifying experts, and reasonable attorney’s fees. Only expenses incurred after the rejection count. The award is capped at what you recover and is applied as an offset against your judgment, so it reduces your check rather than creating a debt you owe out of pocket. Our related discussion of what an injury lawsuit actually costs a client walks through how those numbers work in practice.
Three conditions limit this rule sharply:
- The defendant has to formally invoke the procedure by filing a declaration with the court.
- The offer has to be in writing, state that it is made under that chapter, spell out the settlement terms, set an acceptance deadline, and be served on every party it is directed to.
- The procedure does not reach class actions, shareholder derivative suits, family law cases, workers’ compensation benefit claims, cases filed in justice of the peace or small claims court, or actions by or against a governmental unit.
A phone call from an adjuster offering you a number does not qualify, and neither does a routine demand letter exchange before a suit is filed.
How Texas Fault Rules Affect What an Offer Is Worth
Any honest valuation of an offer has to account for how a Texas jury apportions blame. The jury assigns a percentage of responsibility to everyone involved, including you. Your damages are then reduced by your own percentage, and if your share exceeds 50 percent, you recover nothing at all.
That rule cuts both directions during negotiation. An adjuster who argues you were 40 percent responsible is trying to justify paying 60 percent of the claim’s value. If the evidence does not support that split, the offer is low and rejecting it is generally the right move. If the evidence does support it, holding out for the full number is a losing strategy. Getting that assessment right before you answer is the whole job.
Does Saying No Mean Your Case Goes to Trial?
Rarely. Filing suit and trying a case are different steps, and a large share of injury claims resolve somewhere between the two. Depositions can surface testimony that changes how both sides read the case. A Texas court can also refer a pending case to mediation, which puts an impartial third party in the room to move both sides toward a number. Many defendants who would not budge before a lawsuit find room to negotiate once a trial date is on the calendar.
Timing is the constraint worth watching. Texas law generally requires you to file suit within two years of the date your claim arises, with limited exceptions, including tolling for claimants who were minors when the injury occurred. Negotiating past that deadline without filing can end a claim that was otherwise worth pursuing, which is why prolonged back-and-forth with an adjuster needs a lawyer watching the calendar.
Talk to Scott Scherr Before You Answer the Adjuster
A low first offer is not the ceiling on your claim, and you do not have to guess whether to take it. Scott Scherr, the board-certified Bryan-College Station personal injury attorney at The Payne Law Group, will review the offer on the table, tell you what it is missing, and handle the negotiation from there. Contact our Bryan office to learn about your legal options. We answer 24/7/365, and consultations are free.