Share on Facebook
Share on X
Share on LinkedIn
By Scott Scherr
Partner
If the driver who hit you claims no traffic laws apply in a parking lot, that is partly true. Fault depends on who used reasonable care, and a pedestrian 50% or less at fault can still recover, minus that share.

In most Texas parking lots, no traffic statute gives pedestrians an automatic right-of-way, yet every driver still has to use ordinary care to avoid hitting people on foot. In practice, a careful driver moves slowly, looks before backing up, and stops for anyone in the aisle. After a crash, fault turns on what each person did, including how fast the driver moved and whether the pedestrian stepped out without warning. As a Bryan-College Station pedestrian accident attorney, Scott Scherr at The Payne Law Group helps injured people across Brazos County prove what happened and recover compensation.

Do Drivers Have to Yield to Pedestrians in Parking Lots?

The Texas Transportation Code sets the right-of-way rules most drivers learned for their license test. Those rules apply to driving on public highways and streets unless a specific rule says it covers another place. The code defines a highway or street as a publicly maintained road open to public traffic. The privately maintained lot outside a grocery store, a restaurant, or an apartment complex in Bryan or College Station does not meet that definition.

A driver who hits someone in a busy grocery store lot might tell the insurance company that no traffic law applied. The injured pedestrian might assume that walking in an aisle carried an automatic right-of-way. Under Texas law, the claim turns on how carefully each person acted.

Some Texas rules that matter for pedestrians do reach into parking lots:

  • The sidewalk at the driveway. A driver pulling into or out of a lot across a public sidewalk must stop and yield to a pedestrian on that sidewalk.
  • Reckless driving. The state’s reckless driving law expressly applies to parking areas a business provides for its customers (private residential property and paid lots or garages are excluded), so a driver who shows willful or wanton disregard for safety there commits a crime.
  • Duties after a crash. In the same business parking areas, a driver who hits someone must stop, check whether anyone needs help, share their name, address, vehicle registration, and insurance company, and give reasonable assistance, such as arranging a ride to a hospital when treatment is clearly needed. Leaving the scene can be a crime.

Outside those situations, the question becomes the one Texas juries answer in every negligence case: did each person use ordinary care?

What Reasonable Care Looks Like for a Driver in a Parking Lot

In a Texas negligence trial, the court tells the jury that ordinary care means the care a person of ordinary prudence would use under the same or similar circumstances. In a crowded lot, the jury asks a practical question: What would a careful driver have done with shoppers, children, and carts moving between parked cars?

A careful driver creeps through the aisles, checks mirrors and the backup camera before reversing, and stops when a person steps into view. A careful driver also keeps the phone down, because a pedestrian can appear from behind an SUV or a delivery van in a second. Scott Scherr looks at each of these choices when he evaluates whether the driver failed to use ordinary care.

Pedestrians also have to use ordinary care. A person who walks behind a car with its reverse lights on, or darts out from between two trucks while looking at a phone, can share responsibility for the collision.

How Is Fault Determined After a Parking Lot Pedestrian Accident?

A Texas jury, or a judge deciding the case without one, assigns a percentage of responsibility for causing the injury to the injured person, each person being sued, and certain others. Before that happens, the injured person has to prove that the driver failed to use ordinary care and that the failure caused the harm. Texas uses the same percentage system in a Bryan car accident claim that arises on a public road.

The property owner can sometimes share responsibility, too. Texas law requires a business to make its property reasonably safe, or to warn customers, about hidden conditions that pose an unreasonable risk of harm when the business knows or should know about them. If a condition such as broken lighting helped cause the crash, Scott Scherr looks at whether the owner should share the blame.

Facts a jury looks at when it sets those percentages include:

  • Speed. A driver cutting diagonally across empty spaces at 20 mph has far less time to react than one moving at walking pace.
  • Visibility. Glare, poor lighting, rain, and tall vehicles parked at the end of a row all affect what each person could see.
  • Reversing. A driver backing out of a space has a limited view to the rear, so a careful driver checks the mirrors and the camera before moving.
  • Distraction. Phone use by either person can explain why nobody stopped in time.
  • Pedestrian movement. A jury considers whether the pedestrian walked in a marked path, crossed the main drive aisle, or stepped out suddenly.

A jury weighs these facts together, so Scott Scherr builds the case by showing how they fit in the seconds before impact.

What Evidence Can Help Prove Liability?

A store parking lot can hold several kinds of proof: security cameras, witnesses, and physical clues. Camera systems record over old video and witnesses go home, so someone has to collect that proof quickly.

The evidence Scott Scherr works to secure after a parking lot pedestrian accident includes:

  • Surveillance video from the store, neighboring businesses, and lot light poles, which camera systems record over after a set period
  • Dash cam footage and video from vehicles with built-in recording systems, including the car that hit you and nearby parked cars
  • Witness statements from shoppers, employees, and cart attendants who saw the driver’s speed or path
  • Photographs of the scene, the sightlines, the lighting, and your injuries
  • Vehicle damage and accident reconstruction that show the point of impact and how fast the car was moving
  • Phone records when there is reason to believe the driver was texting or on a call

Ask the property owner in writing to keep the video as soon as possible. Scott Scherr can send that request for you.

Can a Pedestrian Still Recover Compensation if They Shared Fault?

Yes, as long as the pedestrian’s share of fault is 50% or less. Texas follows a proportionate responsibility rule. An injured person found partly at fault can still recover, and the award is reduced by that percentage. A pedestrian found 20% at fault for a $100,000 injury, for example, would recover $80,000. A pedestrian found more than 50% at fault recovers nothing.

An insurer pays less for every point of fault it shifts onto you, so adjusters have a reason to blame the pedestrian in a parking lot case. Texas law also sets a two-year deadline, with some exceptions, to file a personal injury lawsuit, counted from the day the claim arises, so waiting too long can end the claim entirely. If a city, county, state, or public university vehicle or employee was involved, written notice of the claim may be due within six months, and some cities require it even sooner.

How Scott Scherr at The Payne Law Group Can Help: Talk to a Bryan-College Station Pedestrian Accident Attorney

Scott Scherr, the Bryan-College Station personal injury attorney at The Payne Law Group, is Board-Certified in Personal Injury Trial Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization, a credential held by fewer than 2% of Texas lawyers. He investigates parking lot crashes across Bryan-College Station and Brazos County and challenges an insurer that tries to shift fault onto the pedestrian. Contact us for a free consultation, available 24/7/365. You pay no attorneys’ fee unless we recover for you.

About the Author
Attorney Scott Scherr is a trial lawyer who is passionate about helping clients get the money they need and deserve. He represents clients in personal injury matters, complex business, and employment matters. Don’t “settle” for just any lawyer – there are a ton of lawyers out there who do the minimum amount of work possible just to settle your claims as quickly as they can, even if the settlement is not necessarily in your best interest. Those lawyers do not get you the amount of money you deserve – you are just another case they want to get off their desk so they can move on to the next one. Many of them are simply afraid to go to trial or to put in the effort to maximize the money you will get. This literally robs you of dollars that should be paid to you. We will give your case the attention it deserves and gets you the most money we can, even if it means more work and taking your case all the way to trial.